Orienting Reflex
Sensing before knowing
Before we can name what is happening, something in us has already turned toward it. Orienting Reflex is an inquiry into that first turning, in the clinic, in organisations and in society: a book in progress, a set of instruments, and a conversation held in public while we find out how much we do not yet know.
“What is it?”
Pavlov called it the “what-is-it?” reflex: the whole-body turn towards something new, before we know what it is. Since Evgeny Sokolov’s work in the late 1950s, almost every account has assumed a comparison. The organism holds a model or an expectation, and orienting fires when something fails to match it. That assumption runs from mismatch negativity through predictive processing to active inference.
Practice suggests something wider. Orienting can compare: put a cauliflower on a lamp in a consulting room and everyone who walks in notices it, without having checked the room item by item. But it need not. A newborn orients with almost no picture of the world to compare against, and sets off its mother’s orienting in turn. Orienting does not require a model or a comparison. It may not even be one thing, but a range: sometimes quick and heuristic, sometimes barely processed, differing with each sense and with how much is arriving at once.
Respond to what you have already defined and you close the collection. Keep it open, as Goethe did with plants and colour, and the sensing carries on.
That distinction has held through everything we have tested so far. Keeping the collection open lets a difficulty find its own route, so that it is dissolved rather than solved, in Russell Ackoff’s sense, and sometimes never named as a problem at all. We are resisting the pull to turn this into a model with tools and a method, because drawing a boundary round an experience defines it before all of it has arrived.
Our osteopath describes it as ease. Holding a patient’s shoulder, he is not judging good or bad through his fingers. He feels, in himself, where it is easier to go, and goes there. When it is right there is a sense of rightness: ease in the system. Its opposite is dis‑ease, kept hyphenated: the discomfort that comes before anything has gone wrong.
Our work is about increasing the variety of sensing in systems at every level, drawing on the cybernetic tradition of Ashby, Pask and Beer, on the biology of the extracellular matrix and on practical knowing.
Open questions
We expected the research to narrow things down. It has widened them. These are the questions we are now working on, and we would welcome your view on any of them.
- Is there a loop alongside Ross Ashby’s two, one outside any hierarchy that meets complexity before the disturbances his loops correct? Or is calling it a loop the very labelling we want to avoid?
- What kind of model does long practice build, if it builds one? Does experience change what can be registered, or what is expected?
- How does one person’s orienting register in another, at a distance, with no ordinary sense involved?
- What happens when the one being sensed is not a person but an organisation of fifty thousand, or a society?
- Does dis‑ease go with simplistic sensing rather than considered sensing, in a body, an organisation or a society? Is skilled sensing a capability a society can lack?
- Is the problem someone brings ever the problem itself, or only the place where it shows?
- Can a machine orient? Data is always a record of a system that has already moved on. If our tools only ever meet the past, what do they tell us about the present?
- With more versions of truth than anyone can absorb, which of them do we act on?
The 4W&T system
Four instruments for conversation and one for anticipation, built on Gordon Pask’s Conversation Theory, with what is learned held in a living knowledge mesh.
Wellspring
Meeting what is sensed before it can be said. A space for the pre-articulate.
Workbench
A practitioner and a partner draw out knowing that lives in hands and habits, and test it by teachback.
Workshop
Shared sense-making across perspectives, where a group finds what none of its members held alone.
Wayfinder
Finding a way through what has been learned, and knowing when you have reached its edge.
Transducer
After Robert Rosen’s anticipatory systems: carrying what has been sensed forward into models of what is coming, and into practical application in the clinic, the organisation and beyond.
The 4W&T instruments are developed by Peter Tuddenham at CoExplorer. Orienting Reflex uses them as its working method.
How we work
Orienting Reflex begins as a joint venture between the United States and the United Kingdom, drawing on the English cybernetic tradition of Ashby, Pask and Beer and the American tradition that grew up alongside it.
Gordon Pask built machines to converse with, from Musicolour in the 1950s to THOUGHTSTICKER in the 1970s: partners in learning, not substitutes for it. We work in that tradition. Our conversations are recorded and transcribed, and a range of large language models help us structure what was said, draft, find and check sources, and build the knowledge mesh. We also put our own claims to several of these models for review, and let them argue with us. This is not an anti-AI project; the question is what has to stay intact in the person holding the tool, so that they can tell when the output appears to be inaccurate. We doubt the models can orient: they work from data, and data is always a record of what has already happened. Every draft is taught back by the person whose knowing it claims to hold, without the page, and corrected wherever the two differ.
Where the material is sensitive, the same process runs on open-weight models hosted in your own country, or entirely on your own premises, so that your data stays sovereign and never leaves your control.
We work in English first. But sensing is shaped by language and culture, and what counts as noticing in one place may pass unseen in another. We welcome partners who want to develop this work in other countries, regions and languages, in their own terms rather than ours.
Knowing Before the Word
Written in conversation by an osteopath, a cybernetician from policing and security, and a learning architect. A ‑nosis is a condition diagnosed from outside; a ‑gnosis is knowing from inside the knowing. One of us works one person with one person, one with organisations of five to fifty thousand, one with society. The book asks whether orienting is one reflex at three scales, and what changes as it carries across them.
Biognosis
The knowing of the living body: what the hand knows before the mind names it.
Organognosis
The knowing of the organised whole: how a practice or an institution senses its own coherence, and what keeps its collection open.
Sociognosis
The knowing of the social field: how a profession or a nation feels what is coming before it can say what it is.
Ways in
Thinking in public
Working notes, open disagreements and the questions they raise, as the book develops. Our first post asked Pavlov’s question, What Is It? The second, We Stopped and Looked, reports what happened when we tested our own claim.
Subscribe on SubstackConversations
Recorded conversations, talks and demonstrations of the instruments at work.
Watch on YouTubeWorking with us
Orienting Reflex is the research. Training and consulting drawn from it, for clinicians, teams and leaders facing complex challenges, will be offered through C3 Sense: Complexities, Challenges, Capabilities. Until it opens, write to us.
Start a conversationThree perspectives
Steve Hewitt
Osteopath of thirty-five years, Ledbury Osteopathic Practice.
Richard Berry
Cybernetician from policing and security, working across innovation, research and public service.
Peter Tuddenham
Learning architect in Gordon Pask’s tradition. Co-Founder, College of Exploration; President, Cybernetics Society.